A limestone and plaster estate beyond a broad green lawn, framed by two mature trees in early autumn light.

Why Most Lot Splits in Cherry Hills Village Are on Hold, and Why the Price of Doing One Could Change

Cherry Hills Village City Hall has not accepted a new subdivision application requiring land dedication since December 10, 2025, and it will not accept one before January 4, 2027. The pause covers sketch plats, preliminary plats, final plats, amended plats and minor subdivisions. It applies to any of these applications that would trigger the city's land dedication or fee-in-lieu requirement.

For an estate parcel marketed on its split potential, that matters twice. The right to divide the land is on hold. The price of using that right is also being rewritten. If the city adopts its consultant's recommendation, the math shifts in a direction few large-lot owners would guess. Splitting a big estate parcel in two would get much cheaper. Carving land into many smaller lots would get more expensive.

What a Split Costs Under the Rule Still on the Books

Section 17-3-30 of the Cherry Hills Village Municipal Code requires a 7.5% dedication of land whenever property is subdivided. That land supports open space, parks, trails and other community facilities. At its discretion, the city may accept a cash fee in lieu of the land, set at the land's fair market value. The requirement dates to 2004.

Because the charge is a percentage of the land, it grows with acreage. In the R-1 district, the minimum lot size is 2.5 acres, so dividing one parcel into two takes at least 5 acres. The city's own illustration assumes land worth $1,000,000 per acre. At that value, a two-lot R-1 split carries a 0.375-acre dedication or a $375,000 fee-in-lieu, all for one new homesite.

That $375,000 is the cost that rarely comes up when a buyer reads "subdividable" in a listing. It also explains why a split in this city is a capital decision, not a paperwork step.

Why the City Stopped the Clock

A court case triggered the pause. At the December 10, 2025 meeting, Community Development Director Paul Workman walked Council through the 7.5% requirement. The minutes then record this: "In light of the 2024 United States Supreme Court decision in Sheetz versus County of El Dorado, staff proposed a temporary moratorium on subdivision applications requiring land dedication or fee in lieu." The ordinance gives its purpose as studying the impact of development on city facilities and adopting regulations to reduce those impacts.

The city adopted the original nine-month moratorium as an emergency ordinance under its police power. Council affirmed it on second reading on February 3, 2026, with an expiration date of September 10, 2026. Because it did not amend the code, it did not need a Planning and Zoning Commission recommendation.

The study ran longer than nine months. In August, staff asked for four more months, for thirteen months in total. The August 4 council packet also stated that "There are no pending applications for subdivisions, and staff has had no conversations with any prospective applicants for subdivisions." Citizen Portal's meeting report says Council passed Council Bill 7 on second and final reading 4–0 on August 18. That extended the moratorium to January 4, 2027.

So the pause is not holding back a crowd of applicants. Its purpose is to make sure the next applicant pays under a rule the city believes it can defend.

The Formula That Changes Who Pays

The city hired consultant TischlerBise, and Council approved the agreement on March 3, 2026. TischlerBise recommends dropping the land-area percentage and charging per new home. The revised August figure is 0.0543 acres per new single-family detached home, made up of 0.0384 acres for parks and 0.0159 acres for trails. In June the figure was 0.049. The consultant's reasoning is that park demand comes from the number of new households, not from how big their lots are. The memo says a per-home charge better meets the Nollan/Dolan/Sheetz test.

The city's illustrations all assume land at $1,000,000 per acre:

Scenario

Current fee-in-lieu

Proposed fee-in-lieu

R-4, 1 acre split into 2 lots

$75,000

$54,300

R-3, 2 acres split into 2 lots

$150,000

$54,300

R-1, 5 acres split into 2 lots

$375,000

$54,300

R-1, 10 acres, up to 5 homes

$750,000

$217,200

R-4, 10 acres, up to 20 homes

$750,000

$1,031,700

Under the proposal, every two-lot split costs about the same, whatever the zone. The district with the largest lots sees the biggest drop. In the city's example, the fee on a 5-acre R-1 split falls by about 86%. The only scenario where the charge rises is the one that creates the most homes.

The per-home figure is high because the city starts with a lot of parkland. TischlerBise counts 18.1 acres of parks and trails per 1,000 residents, against a national average of 10.2. A dedication formula is built to keep that level of service as the city grows. Even so, one new estate lot uses about one-twentieth of an acre of the park and trail system.

Council Has Not Signed Off

Nothing in that table has been adopted, and the June 16 discussion shows why the final numbers are still open. According to the June 16 minutes, Mayor Katy Brown said the goal of the policy and the Master Plan is to preserve open space:

"0.049 acres of open space dedication is useless."

She questioned whether a formula that small would lead to fee-in-lieu payments on every subdivision. Councilor Robert Eber said the fee would not raise enough for the city to buy an open space parcel. Councilor Doug Robinson said he was not yet persuaded. In his view, the city is a land-based place with large lots, and the current model discourages subdivisions and encourages land dedication.

Mayor Brown suggested one fix that would close much of the gap. Guest houses are allowed alongside a main home in the R-1, R-2 and R-3 districts, so each new lot in those districts could count as two potential units. By her account, that would roughly double the requirement and bring it closer to today's numbers in many scenarios. Mayor Pro Tem Earl Hoellen said singling out guest houses runs against the city's arguments against state housing mandates.

Staff answered in the August memo. Existing guest houses are assumed to be included in Census household figures, and the city has never assumed every new R-1 or R-2 lot will get one. A guest-house impact fee due at building permit would be a separate policy question and would likely need its own nexus study. Staff advised against a minimum dedication. They said a floor set without regard to a project's actual impact is unlikely to pass the "rough proportionality" test.

The legal reasoning behind the study favors smaller, per-home charges. Some members of the Council that will vote on it have spoken in support of the land-based approach, which Councilor Robinson said discourages subdivisions. The final ordinance has to reconcile those positions.

What This Means for Land Priced on Its Split Potential

A large Cherry Hills Village parcel can carry two values. One is the value of the home and land as they stand. The other is the value of the option to divide them later. Under the current code, the city's own example puts a $375,000 charge on that option for a two-lot R-1 split. Under the consultant's recommendation, the same split would cost $54,300. Those figures rest on the city's assumed $1,000,000 per acre, not on any appraisal. But they show how far the option's value could move on a council vote with no date yet.

The remaining steps are public and in order:

  1. TischlerBise finalizes the nexus study. As of early August, it reported its fourth task 90% complete and its fifth 10% complete.
  2. Staff and the City Attorney's Office draft a Council Bill with the new dedication language.
  3. The Planning and Zoning Commission makes a recommendation.
  4. City Council holds a first reading "at a future Council meeting," followed by a decision.
  5. The moratorium expires January 4, 2027, unless Council extends it again.

The October 6 council agenda listed no nexus study or dedication code item.

A separate measure on the same subject comes first. Ballot Question 2C is on the November 3, 2026 municipal ballot. It would add Section 1.6 to the Home Rule Charter, declaring planning, zoning, density, land use, structures and development to be local matters. It would also state that the city is not required to implement state mandates on those subjects. The October Village Crier prints the full text. 2C does not set a dedication formula. Whatever the result, the nexus study answers to the federal proportionality standard that set this process in motion.

A Few Questions That Come Up

Does the moratorium stop someone from building a new home on an existing lot? According to the December 10, 2025 minutes, the moratorium applies to sketch, preliminary, final and amended plats and minor subdivisions that require land dedication. Director Workman confirmed that applications not requiring dedication are not subject to it.

Is $1,000,000 per acre the actual land value in Cherry Hills Village? It is the round figure the city used in its illustrations. The current code sets the fee-in-lieu at the land's fair market value, so real figures depend on the specific parcel.

Would a guest house count as a second unit under the new formula? Not under the current recommendation. Staff described a guest-house impact fee as a separate policy decision that would likely need its own study.

If you own or are considering acreage in Cherry Hills Village and its split potential is part of the value, it helps to price that potential under both the current rule and the proposed one, and to keep tracking the city's process. Lisa Taylor follows these council decisions closely and can help you see how they bear on a specific property. Let's Connect.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

About the Author

Lisa Taylor, Denver real estate agent

Lisa Taylor

Broker Associate, Compass Denver


Lisa Taylor is one of Denver's most sought-after real estate advisors, recognized among the top 1% of REALTORS® nationally and ranked the #2 individual agent at Compass Denver. A Denver native and licensed professional since 1992, she has spent more than 25 years guiding clients through luxury home sales in Cherry Creek, Cherry Hills, Greenwood Village and beyond. Her accolades include the Black Diamond Award, Five Star Real Estate Agent honors, and multiple 5280 Top Agent selections, and her work has been featured on HGTV's House Hunters and The American Dream. Nearly 90% of her business comes from repeat and referral clients, a reflection of the trust she builds through every transaction. A Regis University graduate, Lisa lives in Denver's Bonnie Brae neighborhood and is passionate about connecting clients to the Denver lifestyle she calls home.

200 Columbine St #500, Denver, CO 80206

Work With Lisa

Her tireless work ethic, knowledgeable market insight, and understanding of customer expectations leave a lasting impression with clients and colleagues and contribute to her outstanding sales and marketing track record.